Welcome to Sileo's New York
Located in Indian Trail, North Carolina, Sileo's New York is a cozy deli offering a taste of the Big Apple with their signature sandwiches, wraps, and triple deckers. Known for their savory Reuben and Philly cheesesteak sandwiches, customers rave about the thin-sliced meats and flavorful dressings. With a menu that caters to both hot and cold deli sandwich lovers, Sileo's New York is a must-visit for those craving authentic New York-style deli fare. Customer reviews applaud the quality and value of the food, making it a go-to spot for breakfast bagels and lunch favorites. Don't miss out on experiencing a slice of New York right in North Carolina at Sileo's New York.
- 6455-A Old Monroe Rd Indian Trail, NC 28079 Hotline: (704) 776-4340
Welcome to Sileo's New York, a hidden gem located at 6455-A Old Monroe Rd in Indian Trail, NC. This deli offers a wide variety of mouthwatering dishes ranging from signature sandwiches to wraps and triple deckers. With a focus on authenticity and quality, Sileo's New York is a must-visit spot for all food lovers.
One of the highlights of Sileo's New York is their signature sandwiches, such as the Italian Sandwich with salami, pepperoni, ham, and provolone, or the Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich loaded with mushrooms, onions, peppers, and provolone. The freshness of the ingredients and the perfect blend of flavors make these sandwiches stand out.
In addition to sandwiches, Sileo's New York also offers delicious wraps like the Chicken and Cheddar Cheese Wrap and the Chef Salad Wrap. Each wrap is packed with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor, making them a satisfying option for a quick and tasty meal.
Customers rave about the Reuben sandwich at Sileo's New York, with one reviewer mentioning how it reminded them of the authentic NYC sandwiches they had in the past. The attention to detail in each dish and the dedication to providing great value make Sileo's New York a top choice for deli lovers.
Whether you're in the mood for a classic deli sandwich or a refreshing wrap, Sileo's New York has something for everyone. The friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, and unbeatable flavors make this deli a standout in the Indian Trail area. Stop by Sileo's New York and experience a taste of New York right here in North Carolina.

Incredible food and great value! I love their Reuben sandwich because it reminds me of the NYC sandwiches I had when I lived there. Delicious meat and savory sauce! I like the fact they have both cold and hot deli sandwiches.

Real deal my wife and I go there for breakfast early in the morning and his breakfast sandwiches are cheaper than McDonald's and Wendy's and better. His raspberry crumb cake from New York is the real deal. It's awesome.

Steve does a fantastic job running his shop! I've been quite a few times now, mainly got breakfast bagels (highly recommend bacon egg and cheese 2 eggs on everything, plain, or cheese bagel) but today I picked up lunch: a turkey Ruben on wheat wrap with garlic parm fries and it is nothing short of fantastic! Meat is thin sliced and reminds me of a chopped sandwich which I love! Thousand island dressing is fantastic! You can tell how much they care by how the package the food and it is always hot and ready when I arrive. Love this place, and the best breakfast bagels I've been able to find in the Monroe/Indian trail/matthews area!

Our first time here today. We ordered a grilled cheese for our granddaughter and a grilled pastrami with coleslaw for my wife and I to share. The grilled cheese was perfect, on white bread. The pastrami sandwich was very good.

I found this place thru yelp. I was getting a MRI at a location in Indian Land and this place was close by. Great decision to come here. I looked at the menu and the thing that drew me in was the fact that I could get a Turkey Reuben on a long roll I've never had that on a long roll before. When I placed the order I just assumed it would come out the way I wanted, he brought it out on rye and I was a little disappointed but it was still bomb. I asked him about getting on a hoagie roll and he said he can do it. So next time I'll make sure to communicate that from the rip. But everything was good if your in the area go support.

The food is completely outstanding but the payment machine at the counter for takeout, where you walk up and order, is one of those deals where you are shamed into leaving a tip and the no tip option is very difficult to find, very tiny print. I'm so over that. I won't be back for that reason. This is getting ridiculous. I tip waitresses big but ordering at the counter? Please just charge me $20 for my excellent sandwich instead of $17 and save us all this grief.

I'm spreading the News, Great sandwiches here I want to be apart of it That old New York ! There's restaurants everywhere But choose to get my sandwich here Back in that old New York! New York! Come on over to Sileo's and get a great sandwich and a taste of New York in NC God Bless all my fellow foodies always

As a native New Yorker, there are some things that I have come to understand that I just won't get again (on a consistent basis) now that I am in Charlotte. Good bagels, for one. Good pizza. And good sub sandwiches. Sure, Publix does a nice job but let's be real, it ain't exactly what I'm used to getting. And don't even bring up Jimmy John's or whatever. So you'll have to forgive my skepticism when I was told to try this little deli next to one of my favorite sports bars and the Sun Valley movie theaters. I didn't even know this place existed. But I ordered an Italian and let me tell you, that first bite made me close my eyes and reminisce. Good Lord this was a good, classic Italian sandwich. So damn good that I brought a couple home. Now the place itself isn't fancy shmancy, it's just a small, cozy deli not unlike the kind you may find in the Bronx. But the subs are simply fantastic. Looking forward to trying their breakfast sandwiches next.

We ordered the Taylor Ham and Cheese Bagel, Bacon and egg bagel, plain bagel with cream cheese and a short stack of pancakes. If your a cream cheese fan they definitely don't short you on cream cheese on the bagel. The bagels were all very good and the short stack of pancakes "taste homemade " per our friend who ordered them. I love the inside of the deli, the menu selections they offered and would absolutely patronage this place frequently for sandwiches if I lived in the area. Nice spot.

Thank you fellow yelpers that's how I found this New York style deli for breakfast on Saturday morning. I had an everything bagel with ham and cheese and egg. It was tasty and bagel tasted fresh. I sat outside and while it overlooks a parking lot it was a quiet cool fall morning and I enjoyed myself. The inside, though fairly small has lots to look at. It is quaintly decorated with New York paraphernalia. I also ordered a Taylor egg sandwich to go and my Wingate bulldog enjoyed it for a late breakfast. Service was good everyone was friendly restaurants seemed clean and I would return and recommend to others. My son even thought it would be worth the trip from Wingate! Plenty of free parking and it is easy in and out of Sun Valley shopping center. Right by the cinema if you are trying to place it.